Movies of Jeanette MacDonald & Nelson Eddy

Rosalie 1937
Directed by W. S. Van Dyke II
MGM B/W

Nelson (as Dick Thorpe) and Eleanor Powell (as Princess Rosalie)

.One of seventeen top grossing films of 1937-1938


Arabella’s notes....

Well, they gave Nelson “Woody” Van Dyke, a Romberg-Gershwin Broadway hit, and an extravaganza that would eventually be filmed over 60 acres of backlot by 27 cameras filming 2,000 extras. Then they took away Romberg and Gershwin, retained a plot suitable only for the stage and then cut costs by using old footage from old rejects.

Louis B. Mayer brought in Cole Porter, a composer of great merit, and then refused to take his advice on the score. Thank heaven he kept Nelson Eddy! The baritone sang magnificently despite the
obvious age difference ( at 36 he should have been out of school!) and his fans were pleased
to see he was in the picture from the start. However, it was widely rumored at the time that
the movie had been tailored to showcase L.B.’s new find, Eleanor Powell.


Look for....

....Ilona Massey (Brenda)
....Ray Bolger (Bill)
....Frank Morgan (King Frederic)
....Edna May Oliver (The Queen)
....Billy Gilbert (First Officer Oloff)
....Reginald Owen (Chancellor)
....George Zucco (General Maroff)
....Virginia Grey (Mary Callahan)
....William Demarest (Army’s coach)
....Jerry Colonna (Second Officer Joseph)
....Philip Terry (a cadet)


Jeanette as the “Girl”
and Nelson as her bandito!
Girl Of The Golden West 1938
Directed by Robert Z. Leonard
MGM Sepia Platinum

. One of seventeen top grossing films of 1937=1938


Arabella’s notes....

No outdoor location, no Technicolor (it had been promised) and why didn’t someone shoot the makeup man! “Pops” Leonard did his best with what the studio deigned to give him but it was an obvious case of cost-cutting again . However, the “team” carried on with some help from Romberg, Kahn and Stothart. But Nelson’s fans didn’t overlook the fact that his scenes were cut up and slapped haphazardly into the whole. But, oh, what gems abide! The hightlights of the film include a “Dance With Me “sequence where Nelson rings Jeanette’s waist with his whip (he practiced long and hard for that one and
Jeanette was very grateful!). Nelson’s solo of “Who Are We To Say/” and Jeanette’s tearful reprise later in the picture, are priceless.


Look for....

....Walter Pidgeon (Jack)*
....Buddy Ebsen (Alabama)*
....Leo Carillo (Mosquito)*
....H.B. Warner (Father Sienna)
....Cliff (Ukelele Ike) Edwards (he was also the voice of Jiminy Cricket in “Pinocchio” (Minstrel Joe)
....Monty Wooley (the Governor)
....Billy Bevan (Nick)
....Noah Beery, Sr. (The General)
....Charley Grapewin (Uncle Davey)
....Bill Cody, Jr. (Gringo/Dick as a boy)
....Jeanne Ellis (young Mary)
*great supporting performances

Sweethearts 1938
Directed by W.S.Van Dyke II
MGM Three-color Technicolor


Nelson and Jeanette...
in the happiest of times!


Oscar Nominations for...

...Best Sound Recording (Douglas Shearer)
....Best Score (Herbert Stothart)

.Special Oscar awarded for Color Cinematography (Oliver Marsh and Allen Davey)

.Photoplay Gold Medal Award for Best Picture of the Year


Arabella’s notes....

What a prize package! The duo of the century with MGM’s most successful director, a Stothart /Victor Herbert score, a Dorothy Parker/Alan Campbell script, Adrian gowns and even COLOR! And then, add to all that, Nelson in easy-to-wear suits and very easy on the eyes. The fans were happy, the critics were happy, the studio was happy and the “singing sweethearts” were overjoyed! What else can I say!

Look for....

....Florence Rice (Kay)*
....Frank Morgan (Felix)*
....Mischa Auer (Leo)*
....Herman Bing (Oscar)*
....Doug McPhail and Betty Jaynes (the Alternates)
....Reginald Gardiner (Trumpett)
....Allyn Joslyn (Dink)
....Fay Holden (Hannah)
....Gene Lockhart (Uncle Augustus)
....Raymond Walburn (Orlando)
....Lucile Watson (Mrs. Marlowe)
....George Barbier (Benjamin Silver)
....Dalies Franz (pianist)
*great supporting performances


Nelson sings "Home, Sweet Home"
Let Freedom Ring 1939
Directed by Jack Conway
MGM Sepia Platinum

Arabella’s notes....

What a change of pace for Nelson! A real, honest-to-goodness red, white and blue Western! No tight pants, no high starched collars and, best of all, no fancy dandy makeup! Even the sepia platinum served to enhance it. Nelson got to carry a gun (of course, he never shot anyone), rob a stage (but all in good fun), fight the bad guys ( with his fists, by gosh), and sing every song (oh, he let Virginia Bruce and Victor McLagen chime in now and then). Nelson loved the part where he printed the newspaper because he had done some of that on his way up. But best of all were the songs. I am going to open up all my windows on the Fourth of July and play “Where Else But Here” to the whole neighborhood. (Of
course, I may need bail money!)

Look for....

....Charles Butterworth (Mackerel)*
....Victor McLagen (Mulligan)*
.... Edward Arnold (Jim Knox)
....Lionel Barrymore (Tom Logan)
....Gabby Hayes (Pop Wilkie)
....Louis Jean Heydt (Ned Wilkie)
....Maud Allen (Hilda)
....Guy Kibbee (Judge Bronson)
....H.B. Warner (Ned Rutledge)
....Raymond Walburn (Underwood)
*great supporting performances


Balalaika 1939
Directed by Reinhold Schunzel
MGM B/W


Nelson. Ilona sing "Si Tu M'Aime"
from "Carmen"

. Oscar Nomination for....
.... Best Sound recording (Douglas Shearer)


Arabella’s notes....

Although his relationship with Louis B. Mayer was widely known to be cool at best, Nelson must have been pleased with these two of L.B.’s European finds....Ilona Massey and Reinhold Schunzel.While Ilona’s voice never quite matched Jeanette’s lyric soprano, the very beautiful Hungarian actress carried her role well. But this was Nelson’s film all the way. His “Song of the Volga Boatman” in Russian, and the duet from “Carmen” were faultless. But it was his “Stille Nacht” (Silent Night) to the Austrians in
the trenches of World War I that was an emotional masterpiece. Not a dry eye in the house!


Look for....

.... Charlie Ruggles (Nicki)*
....Joyce Compton (Masha)*
....Dalies Franz (Dimitri)*
....Frank Morgan (Ivan)
....Lionel Atwill (Professor Marakov)
....C.Aubrey Smith (General Karagin)
....George Tobias (Slaski)
....Walter Woolf King (Sibirsky)
....Florence Shirley (Lily)
....Philip Terry (Smirnoff)
*great supporting performances

New Moon 1940
Directed by Robert Z. Leonard
MGM B/W

Nelson and Jeanette have an island wedding

Arabella’s notes....

Yes, I’ve read all the reviews. Critics write reviews. People watch movies. I am one of the people and I liked this movie. Okay, so I’m a hopeless romantic. What’s so bad about that? Yeah, even Nelson called it “Son of Naughty Marietta” and I almost never disagree with Nelson. Now, while I have to admit there are a lot of similarities, I really believe this movie has legs of its own. Forgive me, Nelson, but who can fault the Sigmund Romberg/Oscar Hammerstein II score? Or Jeanette’s solos, “One Kiss” and
“Lover, Come Back To Me”? And anyone with romance in their soul will melt with that garden
duet of “Wanting You”! Plus there’s the stirring “Stouthearted Men” that will forever be a part of
the Nelson Eddy legacy. Forget those passionless critics! This one is a keeper!


Look for....

....Mary Boland (Auntie Valerie de Roussac)
....Dick Purcell (Alexander)
....Stanley Fields ITambour)
....George Zucco (Vicomte Ribaud)
....H.B.Warner (Father Michel)
....Grant Mitchell (Governor of New Orleans)
....Bunty Cutler (Julie)
....Florence Shirley (Marquise della Rose)


Nelson and Jeanette toast their "Dear Little Cafe"

Bittersweet 1940
Directed by W. S. Van Dyke II
MGM Technicolor

. Oscar Nomination for ....
....Best Color Cinematography (Oliver T. Marsh and Allen Davey)
....Best Color Interior Decoration (Cedric Gibbons and John S. Detlie)


Arabella’s notes....

MGM finally treats our stars to full Technicolor, Adrian gowns, a Noel Coward script and even some Rockettes! But, true to form, the studio assassins descended to shred the script, scrap most of the score and generally commit mayhem. I heard Noel Coward actually cried! But the dynamic duo (or in this case, trio) did wonders with what was left.

The remaining Coward music with additions by Gus Kahn, the guiding hand of Herbert Stothart and two perfect voices saved the day and the movie. Nelson had an abbreviated death scene and somewhat less camera footage but his voice was never better. Jeanette struggled with the ingenue role but her character regained maturity and momentum as soon as she got to Vienna. P.S. When Nelson sang “Tokay” I had the irresistable urge to go out and buy some!

Look for....

....George Sanders(Baron von Tranisch)*
....Edward Ashley (Harry)
....Diane Lewis (Jane)
....Ian Hunter (Lord Shayne)
....Felix Bressart (Max)*
....Curt Bois (Ernst)*
....Herman Bing (Market keeper)*
*great supporting performances

The Chocolate Soldier 1941
Directed by Roy del Ruth
MGM B/W

Nelson goes "under cover" as Vasili

.Oscar Nominations for ....

....Best Black and White Cinematography (Karl Freund)
....Best Sound Recording (Douglas Shearer)
....Best Scoring of a Musical Picture (Herbert Stothart and Branislau Kaper)


Arabella’s notes....

Well, actually, this is “The Guardsman” disguised as “The Chocolate Soldier”! George Bernard Shaw, on whose play the original operetta was based, wanted more money than L.B. Mayer would shell out. So they kept the title and used the old Lunt and Fontanne vehicle “The Guardsman”. Then they plucked Rise Stevens out of the Met and, lo and behold, an operetta for Nelson without Jeanette, who was off doing a movie without Nelson. Now we have talked about makeup and Nelson’s aversion to it but in this
movie, they really throw the pancake at him along with a full beard and bushy eyebrows. He
became a veritable Russian bear of a man. Oh, at times he was still his beautiful blond self as Karl, the jealous husband. But disguised as Vasili, he puts his wife’s feet to the fire, figuratively speaking, and enchants all of us. Wait until you hear him do “The Song of the Flea’!

Look for....

....Nigel Bruce (Bernard)*
....Florence Bates (Pugsy)*
....Nydia Westman (Liesel)*
....Charles Judels (cafe owner)
*great supporting performances


The Playboy and his Angel
I Married An Angel 1942
Directed by Maj. W. S. Van Dyke II
MGM B/W

.Arabella’s notes....

Well, here it is...the last film for the “singing sweethearts”. I guess all good things must
come to an end but the fans were devastated. And the movie wasn’t their best, either. But
the music was, and still is, marvelous! A score by Rodgers and Hart, carefully handled by
Herbert Stothart did wonders. But by this time the team was weary of bad scripts and
studio demolition. “Woody” who was now back from the wars, did the best he could but
the critics crucified it. This is a movie only Jeanette and Nelson fans will love. But there
are many of them out there.

Look for....

....Binnie Barnes (Peggy)*
....Mona Maris (Marika)
....Douglass Dumbrille (Baron Szigetti)*
....Leonid Kinski (Zinski)
*great supporting performances.

Phantom of the Opera 1943
Directed by Arthur Lubin
Universal Technicolor

Nelson, Susannah and "Lullaby of the Bells"

Oscars....
....Best Color Cinematography (Hal Mohr and W. Howard Greene)
....Best Color Interior Decoration: (Alexander Golitzen, John B. Goodman, Russell A. Gausman and Ira
     S. Webb)
.Oscar Nominations....
....Best Sound recording (Bernard Brown)
....Best Scoring in a Musical Picture ((Edward Ward)


Arabella’s notes...

At Universal, Nelson gets to sing opera while Claude Rains prowls the underground caverns and scares a lot of people to death! And he doesn’t look too bad in that black hair and mustache (although I prefer my favorite baritone naturally blond!). But I resent the fact that he doesn’t get the girl. In fact, no one gets the girl for keeps, not even Claude. Susannah Foster lends her tremendous talent to the role of Christine DuBois, the soprano to Nelson’s baritone and they really make beautiful music together. With the help of Raoul the police inspector ( Edgar Barrier),Nelson gets to rescue her from the evil
Phantom. Then she runs off into the crowd and leaves them both clueless.

Look for....

....Leo Carrillo (Signor Ferretti)
....Hume Cronyn (Gerard)
....Steven Geray (Vercheres)
....J. Edward Bromberg (Amiot)
....Jane Farrar (Biancarolli)


Nelson becomes “Willie the Whale”
Make Mine Music 1946
A Walt Disney Production
RKO Technicolor

.Arabella’s notes....

Nelson always wanted to do it all and here he proves he really can..in soprano, tenor, baritone and bass...and a 100 voice choir, all of them Nelson! He is every character in this animated fantasy and he also narrates the story while he is doing it. This is a great family treat even though Nelson only does 10 minutes of it. Oh, and if I forgot to mention it, Nelson gets his third death scene...at the hands of a harpoon-carrying opera impresario! Warn the kiddies!

Look for the voices of....

....Dinah Shore
....Jerry Colonna
....Sterling Holloway
....Andy Russell
....The Andrews Sisters

Northwest Outpost 1947
Directed by Allan Dwan
Republic B/W

Ilona gives Nelson a cold shoulder

Arabella’s notes...

This is Nelson’s last film. Oh, he didn’t leave us without anything. He went on the radio and on the road to make our lives better with music. In this movie he is back in the hands of the Russians and Ilona Massey (not a bad place to be). But strangely, the Russians have left Russia for Hollywood. Well, not quite. Hollywood wasn’t there yet. It was really Fort Ross and at that time it belonged to the Russians. Luckily they used oil lamps and oil was cheap back then! Nelson plays a watchdog for the American government who also keeps peace between the Russians, the Indians and the Mexicans. Sound familiar? But he falls in love with a newly arrived Russian emigre (Ilona) who is secretly married to a
villainous prisoner sent there in exile.Oh, my! While they are working themselves out of this predicament, there are lovely songs sung including Nelson’s “Russian Easter Hymn” and ‘One More Mile To Go”.

Look for....

....Elsa Lanchester (Princess Tatiana)
....Joseph Schildkraut (Count Igor)
....Hugo Haas (Prince Nickolai)
....Peter Whitney (Volkoff)
.... Jay Silverheels (later Tonto in the Lone Ranger series)(Indian Scout)