Arabella's Notes

Broadway Nights 1937
Directed by Joseph C. Boyle
First National B&W


An early picture
Barbara's first film was a silent "with sound effects and background music". She was tested for the lead as Fanny Fay, a dancer married to a compulsive gambler played by Sam Hardy. The director explained that the role was an emotional one and required her to cry on cue. But the cue came and the tears didn't and Barbara, who had cried buckets on stage in "The Noose", couldn't do it in front of the cameras. She lost the lead and had to be satisfied with a much smaller part as Fanny's backstage pal. In the credits, she was listed fifth as "Barbara Stanwyck, dancer" two rungs up from Sylvia Sidney who also made her debut in this film. Barbara forever erased it from her memory and documented her career from her first talkie. Before it was released, she had gone back to the stage.


Ladies of Leisure 1930
Directed by Frank Capra
Columbia B&W

Barbara and Lowell Sherman
Stanwyck meets Capra and it would change the course of Barbara's career. The source material for the original script was Milton Herbert Gropper's "Lady of the Evening" but Capra hated it. This was to be his fifth "talkie"but his first "woman's picture". He summoned a panel of scriptwriters for a brainstorming session and in 3 days Jo Swerling came up with a screenplay.

In the new script the hero, a society painter, meets Kay, a party girl, on a lonely country road. She finds his wallet in the coat she borrowed, returns it and ,voila!, romance blossoms. The tale of how Barbara was first introduced to Capra varied but they all agreed it wasn't Stanwyck's idea. She refused to test for it and the interview with Harry Cohn didn't go well either. But an earlier test that she had done using bits from "The Noose" won her the part.

While working on this picture, Capra learned that with Stanwyck, the first take was the best take. Edward Bernds, who worked with Capra on many of his films, later remarked "That first take with Stanwyck was sacred". Capra also taught Barbara that screen acting was done with the eyes. If the audience didn't feel it there, dialogue was of little consequence. This was considered Barbara's breakthrough movie.

Night Nurse 1931

Directed by
William Wellman
Warner Bros. B&W


Tender, loving care
Harry Cohn loaned Barbara to Warner's for a second time to star opposite Ben Lyons as a nurse who suspects all is not right in the house where she works. Clark Gable ( on loan from MGM) and Joan Blondell are in supporting roles. Barbara and Joan had become good friends during the filming of "Illicit" and Clark was on his way to becoming Tinseltown's newest screen lover.

In this film, Wellman dressed him in black and he got to punch Barbara in the nose and steal food from two little girls...a far cry from the Rhett Butler he would become. Barbara would later recall that by the time "Night Nurse" was released, Gable was so popular that marquees "simply said CLARK GABLE and left Ben and me out completely." Barbara gained momentum in the film but her success was making problems at home. Frank was bombing in his latest film ventures and began drinking heavily.

 

The Bitter Tea of General Yen
Directed by Frank Capra

Columbia B&W


Stanwyck and Nils Asther
Miscegnation! ...a big no-no with the Hays Office and an exciting premise for Capra and Stanwyck! Barbara plays a New England woman intrigued by a Chinese warlord. Capra thought he could get it past the censors by using a white actor made up as an Oriental but it didn't work. And Asther's eyelid makeup exposed his eyes to the glare of the cameras and almost blinded him. Critics praised the stars for their portrayals and "sensuous atmospherics" but called the story implausible. Variety warned that "seeing a Chinaman attempting to romance...a supposedly decent young American woman is bound to woke adverse reaction". But an Australian scandal sheet was more explicit: "..a detestable story of a loathsome Chinese bandit pawing and mauling a white woman..." It was quite evident the world was not ready to shed its prejudices. Scheduled for at least a two week run at Radio City, it was pulled after one week!
This was the only Capra film until "Lost Horizon" not set in America.

Annie Oakley 1930
Directed by George Stevens
..RKO B&W

Stanwyck and Foster!
Barbara played the role of Phoebe Ann Oakley Mozee as an intelligent farm girl competing in a man's world. She wouldn't have played it any other way. The screenplay by Joel Sayre and John Twist let her win the contest without losing the man and it was one of her best performances. The studio never let it be known that the role originally was to go to Jean Arthur but Jean turned it down.
Melvyn Douglas and Preston Foster completed the top end of the cast. But it was the an Indian billed as Chief Thunderbird in the role of Sitting Bull that stole the picture and had the audience rolling in the aisles. Phoebe became famous again when the story was re-made into a musical called "Annie Get Your Gun".

 

His Brother's Wife 1936
Directed by W.S.Van Dyke II
MGM B&W

Barbara and Robert Taylor
"One-Take Stanwyck" and "One-Take Woody" made time fly on this movie set! In the meantime, the publicity department was getting mileage out of the Stanwyck-Taylor romance. Babs plays a nightclub hostess that Robert dumps to do jungle research and she gets even by marrying his brother. But in the end she gets spotted fever and Taylor gets her. Frank Nugent called Taylor "the Crown Prince of Charm" and heir apparent to Clark Gable. On screen Barbara and Taylor seemed to have chemistry but off the set they had almost nothing in common.


 

Stella Dallas 1937
Directed by King Vidor
United Artists B&W


Barbara and Marjorie Main

This was the movie Barbara always wanted to do but everyone was testing for it. Olive Higgins Prouty's tale told of an awkward young woman who gives her love and her hand in marriage to an unhappy wealthy guy who leaves her to care for their young daughter alone.

Goldwyn did it in 1925 with great success and now wanted to do it again. He ordered a new screenplay and wanted William Wyer to direct but Wyler was on loan to Warner's for "Jezebel" so Goldwyn sent for King Vidor. Barbara put aside her hatred of screen tests and agreed to test for it. This part would require a great deal because Barbara had no idea how mothers felt about their daughters. She had really been neither. With Anne Shirley who was to play her daughter, they played out the birthday scene. Barbara got the job. The movie was released in 1937 and grossed more than two million dollars. Stanwyck was up for Best Actress, Anne Shirley for Best Supporting Actress but both lost. Although she would be nominated three more times, Barbara regretted this loss the most.


Golden Boy 1939
Directed by Rouben Mamoulian
Columbia B&W


Stanwyck and Holden!

Clifford Odets’ Play was one with a social agenda. Frank Capra wanted it but Rouben Mamoulian owned it. Finally after great amounts of money had been bid for the rights between Capra and Mamoulian, Harry Cohn stepped into the fray. Cohn, with his strange persuasive powers, convinced Mamoulian to do it for onlythe price he paid for it and direct it as well. However, the screenwriters had to do several revisions to adhere to Production Code rules .
Barbara played Lorna Moon, the mistress of a fight promoter, who uses her to seduce a sensitive young violinist into the lucrative boxing game. Cohn wanted either Luther Adler (who played the part on Broadway) or Tyrone Power for the part of the violinist but agreed to go with an unknown.
While watching a test being run on an actress for another part, he was struck by the actor feeding her lines. And so William Holden became Barbara Stanwyck’s ‘golden boy’. She coached him when Cohn wanted to replace him, reading the next day’s lines with him in her dressing room every night.
She also worried about Holden's habit of nipping alcohol for courage to do the scenes. She never realized at the time it would eventually lead to his death. But every April 1st, the anniversary of the movie’s starting date, Holden sent her two dozen roses and a white gardenia. The week “Golden Boy” was launched in New York, the war started in Europe.

The Lady Eve 1941 .
Directed by Preston Sturges
Paramount B&W


Stanwyck & Fonda!

Preston Sturges wrote it and Preston Sturges directed it. He promised Barbara to write something for her that would fit her like a glove and he delivered. Sturges also borrowed Fonda from Fox to play “Hopsie” and discovered to everyone’s surprise that the actor, for all his Lincolnesque roles to date, had a flair for light comedy. The story was an Adam and Eve re-creation with all of the symbolism thrown in. It even opens with Barbara (as Jean) dropping a half-eaten apple on Hopsie’s head! Oh, by the way, Hopsie is also a snake collector! Charles Coburn is an excellent choice as the father-con man and William Demarest is at his best as Hopsie’s “keeper”. Barbara had a wonderful time filming “...Eve” with a congenial, fun-loving cast and amiable director. Henry Fonda does 5 pratfalls in the movie and lived to tell about it. This was also Stanwyck’s first “fashion” picture and she had Edith Head to design her fabulous wardrobe.

At last, La Stanwyck was a gorgeous sexy clothes horse! The movie grossed $115, 000 in its first three weeks and today is considered a screen classic



.

Meet John Doe 1941
Directed by Frank Capra
Warner Bros. B&W

Stanwyck & Cooper!

Capra had a cast before he even had a script. Gary Cooper, Edward Arnold, Walter Brennan, James Gleason, Spring Byington and Barbara had all signed to be in his next movie sight unseen. The movie was a morality play inside a stinging comedy based on a story from an old issue of Century magazine. The female lead was Anne, a newspaper woman, with just the cutting edge Stanwyck could play so well. “John Doe” was a fabrication Anne had created about a potential suicide and she had to find someone to fit it.

She chose Long John Willoughby,a down-and-out baseball player played by Cooper. Things get messy (as plots are apt to do) and the real “Doe” decides to go to the ledge. The ending was known only to the four top cast members while the others got their parts scene by scene. Barbara was good but the critics kudos went to Gary Cooper as John Doe. He even landed on the cover of Time.

Ball of Fire 1942
Directed by Howard Hawks
Columbia B&W

Barbara and the 7 profs!

There is an unwritten law in Hollywood that successful teams should get up to bat again and Cooper and Stanwyck were the Team of the Day after “Meet John Doe”. Sugarpuss O’Shea was a burlesque dancer running from the law right into a nest of naive professors updating an encyclopedia. Soon both the law and her gangster boyfriend want to neutralize Sugarpuss, while prof Cooper is just trying to understand her language. Barbara was sensational as Sugarpuss. Billy Wilder and Charles Brackett co-authored a bang-up script and Hawks provided stiletto sharp direction.

Babs has a great intro in bare midriff and sparkles doing “Drum Boogie” with Gene Krupa. It was booked into Radio City for December of 1941. Unfortunately the nation’s attention was riveted elsewhere. The Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor!

When the Oscars were finally announced, Barbara was mentioned for three movies (“The Lady Eve”, “Meet John Doe”, and “Ball of Fire”) and nominated for the latter. But on the big night, Joan Fontaine won for “Suspicion”
.

Double Indemnity 1944
Directed by Billy Wilder
Paramount B&W

“MacMurray meets Stanwyck!

This would be Barbara Stanwyck’s most talked about picture and, in that blonde wig, her most famous look. They had to use a wig because Barbara wouldn’t dye her hair even when it turned gray. Wilder was the studio’s hottest writer-director and , with Raymond Chandler, planned to override the Production Code and develop James M. Cain’s novel about two adulterers planning to kill the woman’s husband for his insurance. In a clever concession to Code rules, they tell the story in flashbacks insuring that the criminals are seen to get their punishment before delving deeper into the story. Fred MacMurray plays the insurance salesman shown confessing to the foul deed into a dictaphone (for the uninformed, that was the early precursor to the tape recorder).

His accomplice was the victim’s wife Phyllis, already dead and a thoroughly despicable woman. It was a role only Stanwyck could play and even she wondered how the role would affect her career. She also knew it was the best script she had ever been offered. Again Barbara was nominated for an Oscar and again she lost..to Ingrid Bergman for “Gaslight”
.


Sorry, Wrong Number 1948
Directed by Anatole Litvak
Paramount B&W

“On the phone!”

Barbara got into bed in this movie and stayed there...with the phone! The script was based on a twenty-two minute radio play written by Lucille Fletcher about a bedridden neurotic who happens to hear a murder being plotted and she is the target! Agnes Moorehead did the radio presentation that was re-broadcast seven times and translated into fifteen languages.

Barbara even carefully researched manic-depressive behavior to give her background into the psyche of this terrified woman in self-imposed confinement and now at the mercy of a murderer. Burt Lancaster, however, was totally miscast as the dull-witted husband. Stanwyck was again nominated for an Oscar but lost to Jane Wyman as “Johnny Belinda”. Now a four-time loser, Barbara quipped at an after-Awards party “If I get nominated next year, they’ll have to give me the door prize, won’t they? At least the bride should throw me the bouquet!”

East Side, West Side 1949
Directed by Mervyn LeRoy
MGM B&W

“Barbara as the scorned wife”

MGM’s first choice for the part of Jessie Bourne was Greer Garson but Mervyn LeRoy insisted on Stanwyck with James Mason as her husband Brandon and Ava Gardner as his playgirl paramour. Also added to the cast was a newcomer named Nancy Davis, recommended by both Clark Gable and Spencer Tracy who had dated her in New York. History would later give her new status as Mrs. Ronald Reagan. Isobel Lennart’s screenplay never deviated from Marcia Davenport’s 1947 best seller but reviewers didn’t give it much credibility. The London newspapers ridiculed Mason’s attempt at an American Mid-Atlantic accent.